***BIG CHANGES IN THE WORKS***

***BIG CHANGES IN THE WORKS***

Be sure to stay tuned to this blog over the next couple of weeks. There are some fundamental changes in the works for this blog.

Showing posts with label opinion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label opinion. Show all posts

March 9, 2011

Why the WI teacher union complaints don't add up... It's in the math.

It seems that every time I travel to my homestead of Buffalo to visit my parents, I must invariably come armed for a debate on current politics and/or labor unions because the conversation inevitably turns down that road. My parents are vigorously pro-union and that is fine if that is what you believe in. Since I have moved out, I have done my own homework and have come to my own conclusions on unions (which are a little less favorable).

It is important to note that though I may have problems with unions, I do not have problems with the individuals who are in them. My parents both work very hard and are very good at what they do. I admire that. I however cannot admire some of the things that labor unions as a whole stand for and advocate.

During my last trip home I performed a thought experiment that I found very provocative. The scenario involves the case of teachers unions that urge cuts to administrator’s salaries as a means of closing budget gaps. Sounds good right? It’s similar to Gov. Cuomo’s recent proposal to cap superintendent salaries (which I actually agree with).

Well, let’s analyze this idea. Just to be fair, I am going to apply this analysis to the Brighton Central School district of which I currently reside in and I will use real numbers where ever possible (referencing and describing assumptions where possible). I am doing this to demonstrate my argument not with political rhetoric but with simple mathematics… a language in which it is far more difficult to lie because we all know how to add, subtract, multiply and divide. Right?

The Brighton Central School district (as of 2010-11) with a budget of $62 million, teaches 3,512 students in 1 high school (gr. 9-12), 1 middle school (gr. 6-8), 1 grade school (gr. 3-5) and 1 elementary school (gr. K-2). The Brighton District has a reputation for being one of the better schools around the Greater Rochester Region (feel free to look at the stats on the school yourself).

Now let’s say Brighton is facing a budget crisis (which they may very well be… I am not sure if they are) and they need to make some cuts. There are 356 professional staff (which I assume means teachers) making a median salary of $59,871. For simplicity, let’s round that to $60,000 and not include additional compensation like bonuses, retirement, health and vacation benefits. (For additional info on average teacher salaries and benefits in various states.)

Let’s count one superintendent, one assistant superintendent (2 total) and one principal and assistant principal for each of four schools (8 total for the district) for a total of 10 administrators. The average salary for a superintendent in NY is $163,000. Let’s just round that up to $170,000 for simplicity and to capture some of the bonuses and added benefits. And assume both chief and assistant super’s make the same salary. Let’s assume our 8 principals (assistant and chief) make $100,000, which is rounded up slightly from the $93,000 figure I found (again, to incorporate bonuses, benefits, etc). I believe these are all fair assumptions. Feel free to point out where they are not.

Now here’s where it gets a little nasty: the district says “We need to cut teacher compensation by 5% to close our budget gap.” The Teacher Union says, “Screw you! Cut the compensation of those rich S.O.B. administrators instead! They are making all the money.” This inevitably leads to name calling, strikes, picket lines, yelling protests and potentially 15 state Senators hiding from their jobs across state lines in say... Illinois. But we’re smarter than that, so let’s put all that aside and look at the numbers, shall we?

On average, a 5% teacher pay cut looks like this:

Each teacher would loose (on average) $3,000 in pay per year while it would save the district just over a million dollars a year, or about 1.7% of the overall district budget. But teachers are middle class working folk, the administrators are rich snobs and make nearly double what the teachers make! Sock those S.O.B’s!

Here’s what a cut to their salary looks like. And we’re going to wring those rich bastards really good… with a 10% pay cut!

Awesome! We slapped those rich administrators with deep cuts of ten and seventeen thousand dollars saving the district a total of… a measly $114,000 a year (or 0.2% of the budget)!

Taking a closer look at the numbers shows that you would have to completely eliminate the salaries of the 10 administrators all together in order to have the same effect as cutting teacher pay a modest 5%..

Why is this? Well, teacher compensation accounts for a far greater percentage of the budget than administrator compensation.Take home message: In a business hierarchy, the people at the bottom are much more of a budgetary expense than the people at the top because there are far more of them. This same analysis could potentially apply to any corporation or business.

I am not advocating that we excessively cut teacher pay. It is a difficult and important job and if you cut it too much, no one will want to be a teacher. Same goes for working as a school administrator. I think in reality, cuts at all levels are going to have to be realized in order to close budget gaps.

There you have it. I probably pissed off a lot of people by pointing this out… but please let me know how the numbers are lying to us.

By the way, I would like to thank my math teachers for teaching me how to think this way. :-)

September 7, 2010

What ever happened to the phrase "In bad taste"?

Terry Jones of the Dove World Outreach center in Gainesville, Florida is planning on burning copies of the Quran (the holy book of the religion of Islam) on September 11. How that is any sort of rational outreach to the rest of the world is beyond me. It's going to put our troops overseas in harms way. He should be prevented from doing this, right?

Well, this is where that annoying libertarian voice in me starts to speak.

People are free in this country to burn the United States Flag in protest, don white robes and burn crucifixes, burn copies of the Quran/Bible, etc., write and air satirical cartoons depicting Jesus and or the Prophet Muhammad, make art works depicting the Virgin Mary out of elephant dung... hell, even an Imam can build a Mosque adjacent to Ground Zero!

What's common between these things? For starters, they are all things that have actually happened (or may happen in the case of Terry Jones' plans)... read the list again, surprising to consider all of this as reality!

One may suggest that these actions are all done "In bad taste". Have we forgotten what this means? There are various things that we are free to do, but choose not to do them because they are simply in bad taste. It is these things that usually are not very helpful at fostering outreach and building bridges to begin with. How much outreach and "bridge-building" is Quran burning (or Mosque building at Ground Zero for that matter) really going to foster? However, the concept of "bad taste" does not seem to matter any more.

Since this is [unfortunately] the case, we are put in a position where we have to civilly disagree. By that I mean we can choose not watch the satirical cartoon and view the piece of artwork we find offensive. We can chose no longer to attend the Dove World Outreach center. Civility is key though because if you wish to disagree by physically harming those who offend you (like those over seas might do towards our troops), that too is "in bad taste" and it just continues the cycle over and over.

June 7, 2010

Episode #1: STFU already!

This is the first edition of something new I am going to try. You know how sometimes there are just certain voices in the world that just keep spouting off to the point where all you want to do is shout "STFU already!!!"? (That's STFU = shut the fu#@ up, for those of you not down with the abbreviations.) Well, here's a column (with hopefully many episodes to come) dedicated to those special people
1. Helen Thomas
Telling the Jews to "Get the hell out of Palestine." Oh my! Could you think of anything more controversial, racial or antisemitic to say? Now I know you are like 320 years old and probably pretty senile, but with all that experience being in the press corps, shouldn't you be better at being an unbiased reporter of the news? Though your stellar record indicates otherwise. So please...
STFU already!!!

2. Paul McCartney
Recently won an award from the Library of Congress (The Gershwin Prize) and upon accepting the award stated how after the past 8 years "...it's great to have a president who knows what a library is." HA HA HA... HA HA HA... oh, look at the celebrity make fun of President Bush's intelligence. So edgy and fresh. We've never seen that before. Except isn't Bush's wife Laura a librarian and a teacher... and didn't President Bush graduate from Yale, which I am pretty sure you need to know how to read in order to be accepted. Come to think of it, Paul, you never even went to college! You're no comedian Paul, so stick to writing songs (though thouse kind of suck anyway).
STFU already!!!

3. Arianna Huffington
According to you the Gulf oil spill was "...a thousand percent Bush-Cheny's fault." OMFG! Thousands of people blaming Haliburton and Bush/Cheny for the spill... really does nothing to solve the problem now does it? How far are people going to push this passing of the blame concept? Gulf oil spill... Bush/Cheny's fault, We're stuck in Iraq... Bush/Cheny's fault, I failed my math test... Bush/Cheny's fault, I have a paper cut on my finger... Bush Cheny's fault.
STFU already!!!

4. Barack Obama (Honorable Mention)
Not too long ago I herd a sound bite where President Obama gave a warning to the Jonas brothers about making a pass on his daughters. "I have 2 words for you... Predator Drones." OK, I am going to have to give the President props here. I withhold my STFU already! and instead deliver a Pretty damn funny! You know there are other fathers worried about their daughters out there who would love to have some Predator Drones at their disposal. he he he.

June 6, 2010

I can't believe I am compelled to write commentary about a spelling bee.

Neetu Chandak, 14 year old Seneca Falls student was recently eliminated from the Scripps National Spelling Bee when she spelled the word paravane incorrectly (incorrectly spelled p-e-r-o-v-a-n-e, for those of you keeping score at home). Incorrect, very sorry, good job, try again next year, end of story... right? Not exactly.

Mom stepped in and protested that her daughter was "mislead" when the judges told her that the word was of Greek origin. O.K., I suppose I understand since the Merriam-Webster dictionary has the etymology of the word placed in French and English origins, but one could argue that if she knew how to spell the word properly to begin with, the judge's actions would not be an issue. Does the average 14 year old even know how to spell this word let alone know if it is Greek, French or Swahili in origin?

I want to give the competitor the benefit of the doubt but this strikes me as a manifestation of society of coddling, entitlement and general protection from failure that some children are raised under. It's not just children doing this though. How many baseball fans this week bitched and moaned because Bud Selig would not (at the time of this post) overturn a botched call that would have given Detroit Tigers pitcher a perfect game?

Also buried in this article is this line:
"The audience gasped, shoulders slumped, and speller after speller was escorted offstage to the comfort room as the 48 semifinalists were whittled down..."

Comfort room?

I've played my share of competitive sports (mainly baseball for 9 years, didn't really get into the competitive spelling scene). I was on teams that had losing seasons (losing every single game) and winning seasons (winning every single game). There was no "comfort room" to retreat to when you lost. You just learned how to shake it off, dust your self off, learn from mistakes made and try harder again next game. Loosing was tough, but it made the winning moments so much more coveted and appreciated.

What are these kids going to do when they get into the real world where there is no "comfort room" to retreat to when bad things happen? There's no comfort room for when you lose your job or your business fails. There's no comfort room to retreat to when you are a surgeon who loses a patient on the operating table due to a mistake. And no amount of protesting from mommy is going to fix life's inevitable bumps and failures. You just need to learn from it and figure out how to move forward.

Maybe I am being too harsh, but perhaps learning from failure is a passing concept.

May 30, 2010

Our Generation’s 3-Mile Island.

This morning I was reading about the tragic oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. You would have to be living under a rock in order to miss this story in the news as it has been going on for the past month. Most recently, BP’s '”top kill” method has unfortunately failed to seal the leak and stop the flow of oil.

As I read the story I realized that we are living our generation’s equivalent of the Three Mile Island disaster. For those of you who are not familiar, the Three Mile Island disaster involved a nuclear power plant located near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania that in 1979, released a significant amount of radiation into the environment. Since this accident, there has not been a single approval or construction of a new nuclear power plant in the United States. During the same time period, other countries have turned to nuclear power as their major source of clean energy production (like France – 78% of electricity from nuclear).

I am willing to believe that history will repeat its self here in the aftermath of the Deep Water Horizon accident and spill. We will likely be very reluctant to grant any more licenses to drill new oil wells within the United States, and more cumbersome regulation will occur for those wells that already exist. From here on it may also be the turning point where some other countries will begin to lead the way in safe extraction and utilization of oil as a resource while we sit on the resources beneath our feet leaving them and unused.

Though the spill in the Gulf is a terrible tragedy, I do not believe that our course should involve quitting the extraction of oil in the same cold-turkey fashion as use of nuclear power. I can imagine that eons ago, the caveman who first discovered fire probably burned him self, maybe his friends/family… perhaps even burned down his house, neighborhood or forest! But did not stop man from working with fire. If we stopped, we could still be living in caves today. We figured it out despite the risks and occasional accidents involved. We were better off for it.